Author Topic: Southpaw  (Read 536 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline brianlarsen

  • Arena Rocker
  • *****
  • Posts: 693
  • Good Vibes 65
Southpaw
« on: February 14, 2020, 04:34:01 pm »
Left, right, left, right…
Have we been marching the wrong way all along?

I'm sure this must be well-trodden ground, but a recent post on left-handed guitars spurs me to share an odd thought I had when I first started learning nearly two years ago.
In my limited experience, the single most difficult aspect for beginners is trying to press the correct strings with the correct fingers to play their first chords. Right-handed people practise and practise something that feels completely unnatural long enough to get used to it. Even experienced players struggle to improve their finger work on the fret: touch, speed, accuracy, vibrato, bends and dare I say ‘dexterity’ (pun intended)
To make things interesting- let’s do this with our non-dominant hand  ::)

How did this come about?

Think about where the guitar came from.
Its earliest form would have been a piece of string (animal gut, plant material…) that made a ‘twang’ when plucked.
Cool  8)
Then someone notices that different length ‘strings’ produce different notes-
Hey presto! The harp, lyre, whatever you want to call them is invented.
Of course, everyone holds the instrument with their non-dominant hand and does the complicated stuff (plucking and strumming) with their dominant one.
So far so good, until-
Some other bright spark notices that if you can shorten the string by pressing it down on a piece of wood (or neck) allowing a lot more notes to be produced  :)
Naturally, everyone was used to plucking with the dominant hand, so the other was used to manipulate the length of string. It just would have been nonsensical and weird to switch and do it the other way around.
Instruments and the playing techniques have become more complicated, but we continue playing and teaching the same way ever since and it would feel completely unnatural for anyone who had learnt something one way to find it easier doing it the opposite way around. The 'reasoning' for keeping the status quo being: imagine trying to do something difficult (accuracy, rhythm, speed) with your BAD hand!  :'(

My son is left-handed and, like many left-handed people, he is more comfortable using his non-dominant hand than the rest of us, primarily because we live in a world that is designed for right-handed people.
He has chosen to play right-hand guitar and base.

I envy him.

Before, everybody piles in and explains how important the right hand is for speed, accuracy and touch/feel, especially later on when you have mastered the basics, I am aware of this and agree- But as Justin always points out, do it slowly and correctly first, then things speed up naturally with practise. Think of all those unfortunates who have given up in the early stages, just because it is so unnatural/difficult to get your fingers to be able to play a couple of chords and enjoy making music in the first place.

Ave Caesar, morituri te salutamus

Offline joueur de guitare

  • Arena Rocker
  • *****
  • Posts: 725
  • Good Vibes 34
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #1 on: February 14, 2020, 04:38:27 pm »
As a righty I can pick/strum better with my right hand than my left.

Why the hell would I want to make playing guitar harder than it is?
Guitars. Fender Highway 1 Tele: Fender Shortboard LE Mustang: Ibanez AS73 semi-hollow: Ibanez SR370 bass: Squier Affinity Strat: Squier Jagmaster.

Offline brianlarsen

  • Arena Rocker
  • *****
  • Posts: 693
  • Good Vibes 65
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #2 on: February 14, 2020, 05:00:39 pm »
My basic point is: learning to play guitar is a complex activity requiring both hands.
For almost all beginners the fretting work is main source of difficulty.

It is reasonable to suggest the dominant hand would be better suited to the task (and yes, the strumming/picking would of course feel less comfortable at the same time)

I am simply suggesting that historical reasons have determined why we learn the way we do rather than rational ones.

You've already paid your dues (and reaped the rewards :) )
It would be pointless for anyone to go back and 'relearn', unless you're a crackpot like Justin  ;)

Offline GregB

  • School Prom Hero
  • **
  • Posts: 52
  • Good Vibes 2
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #3 on: February 14, 2020, 06:04:53 pm »
Well I’m afraid I’ll have to disagree and say I believe for the vast majority of people there’s naturally more rhythm in your dominant hand, I accept there will be exceptions of course.

Ignoring the guitar for a moment if I dare say such a thing try just tapping your hand on a table or your chest and see which hand feels better or can mix it up better. I don’t believe it’s a historical thing at all just using the tools your given to the best of their ability.

Offline joueur de guitare

  • Arena Rocker
  • *****
  • Posts: 725
  • Good Vibes 34
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #4 on: February 14, 2020, 06:11:45 pm »

I am simply suggesting that historical reasons have determined why we learn the way we do rather than rational ones.



Most stringed instruments are 'fretted' with the left hand. If it were easier to fret with the right hand, generations of violinists/cellists/double bassists/mandolin players would have done so.
Guitars. Fender Highway 1 Tele: Fender Shortboard LE Mustang: Ibanez AS73 semi-hollow: Ibanez SR370 bass: Squier Affinity Strat: Squier Jagmaster.

Offline stitch101

  • All Time Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 5030
  • Good Vibes 182
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #5 on: February 14, 2020, 07:04:32 pm »
The Lyre goes back at least to 2000 bc some claim 3000.
The guitar goes back to around the 1500s that gave humans 3500 years
to figure it out.

He's a trick to use to figure out if a kid should play right or left handed.
With out telling them start to play air guitar and watch which way they naturally
play air guitar.
Works with snow boarding as well. Run and slide on some ice. Which foot do you
automatically put out front? 

Offline skinnyT

  • School Prom Hero
  • **
  • Posts: 54
  • Good Vibes 3
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #6 on: February 14, 2020, 07:47:40 pm »
I am left handed and play left handed. I have tried right handed and it feels totally alien. I have to disagree that fretting is the most difficult thing. For me I have struggled much more with strumming.

People should play the way that feels correct for them and stop listening to people that tell them otherwise.

Offline brianlarsen

  • Arena Rocker
  • *****
  • Posts: 693
  • Good Vibes 65
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #7 on: February 14, 2020, 08:28:20 pm »
@Greg
Of course your rhythm is better in your dominant hand. But you'll be in trouble if you don't learn it in your left hand too.

@Joueur
I have no doubt that it would be easier to fret any stringed instrument with your dominant hand.
The question is whether that advantage is outweighed by the greater difficulty in strumming/picking.

@Stitch
I can think of a number of things we humans have been doing for thousands of years, which neither make sense, nor are good for us.
All your example will show is if the kid is right or left-handed. It's natural to think that 'playing the guitar' is done with the right hand. That's what makes the noise. Any right-handed person will try to make the noise with their right hand.

I'm just doing the thought experiment here.
Reason tells me that difficult tasks are more easily with your dominant hand.
In the beginning for me, the most difficult task was the fretwork- probably still is.
You guys are way beyond that stage now, so it probably just sounds ridiculous.
I'm just curious when (and why) the 'difficulty' levels even out and go the opposite way.

I think I read somewhere that Mark Knopfler (a lefty) chose to play right-handed guitar to get better vibrato? 

I better go practise though, rather than [ mod note - swear word deleted] try to reset the guitar world  ;D




« Last Edit: February 15, 2020, 09:57:42 pm by close2u »

Offline Drubbing

  • Stadium Superstar
  • ******
  • Posts: 3227
  • Good Vibes 101
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #8 on: February 15, 2020, 12:44:25 am »
My basic point is: learning to play guitar is a complex activity requiring both hands.
For almost all beginners the fretting work is main source of difficulty.

I am simply suggesting that historical reasons have determined why we learn the way we do rather than rational ones.

You've already paid your dues (and reaped the rewards :) )
It would be pointless for anyone to go back and 'relearn', unless you're a crackpot like Justin  ;)

I had no idea of the guitars history when I picked up a guitar. I knew that guitars were right handed, but that instantly felt wrong to me, and so I played it left handed. Just like I air guitar - which is THE best test.

Everyone is different. Left handers tend to be more ambidextrous than most, that's why some can play RH, but it depends how their handedness works. Like your Knofler example.

For me, my left had natural rhythm and my right didn't have any alien feeling forming chords, so I had a head start on many beginners.

When I flip a guitar, as Justin did for his left lessons, I get how it must feel for many beginners, But you have to allow for handedness being a factor in how 'bad' it feels. Not every beginner finds everything awkward.

This is the key point so many who hand out the 'learn RH' advice, fail to register. These are probably people who struggled to learn, and assume that's every beginners expereince, and lefts should just 'work harder' like they had to.

My son has been learning at school and has had no difficulty fretting strings. Chords are difficult, but that's because of his soft fingers, intermittent practice and poor technique - he can form the shapes without frustration. It's not always about L or R hand, but how natural motor skills are.
« Last Edit: February 15, 2020, 11:06:40 am by Drubbing »

Offline GregB

  • School Prom Hero
  • **
  • Posts: 52
  • Good Vibes 2
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #9 on: February 15, 2020, 10:00:53 am »
@Greg
Of course your rhythm is better in your dominant hand. But you'll be in trouble if you don't learn it in your left hand too.

So you admit I’m right then try to argue the opposite. I didn’t hear anyone including me say most had no rhythm in their less dominant hand just less than the dominant. So your saying I’m in trouble if I don’t make the less dominant hand as good as the dominant.

I think your right, stop talking [mod edit - obscenity removed ... please tone down the comments thank you] and crack on with the practice, perhaps you should try left handed  ;D
« Last Edit: February 15, 2020, 03:39:10 pm by close2u »

Offline brianlarsen

  • Arena Rocker
  • *****
  • Posts: 693
  • Good Vibes 65
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #10 on: February 15, 2020, 11:20:19 am »
@Drubbing
Always interesting to get other folks personal experiences and views-
Thanks

@GregB

Hi Greg
I started this thread in the Just Chatting section rather than muddy the original post asking for left-handed advice, as I knew it was contrary to perceived wisdom. There's nothing wrong with questioning long-held traditions and views. It can be a good learning exercise.

The tone of your comment suggests my questions or responses have irritated you somewhat.
I am sorry for any offence caused.
Cheers
« Last Edit: February 15, 2020, 01:30:28 pm by close2u »

Offline GregB

  • School Prom Hero
  • **
  • Posts: 52
  • Good Vibes 2
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #11 on: February 15, 2020, 02:05:48 pm »
@Drubbing
Always interesting to get other folks personal experiences and views-
Thanks

@GregB

Hi Greg
I started this thread in the Just Chatting section rather than muddy the original post asking for left-handed advice, as I knew it was contrary to perceived wisdom. There's nothing wrong with questioning long-held traditions and views. It can be a good learning exercise.

The tone of your comment suggests my questions or responses have irritated you somewhat.
I am sorry for any offence caused.
Cheers

No no offence caused at all, it’s all good. I just disagree but didn’t intend to cause any discomfort.

And to the mods my apologies, I assumed incorrectly there would be an auto hashtag filter on such words as I’d seen it in this thread but perhaps that’s a manual entry, anyway it won’t happen again  :)

Offline brianlarsen

  • Arena Rocker
  • *****
  • Posts: 693
  • Good Vibes 65
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #12 on: February 15, 2020, 08:13:02 pm »
Bit hard on you Greg- being pulled up for repeating my poor choice of language  ;)
All good.
Have a productive guitar weekend  :)

Offline CT

  • Stadium Superstar
  • ******
  • Posts: 1526
  • Good Vibes 77
    • YouTube
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #13 on: February 15, 2020, 08:32:57 pm »
This is one of those scorched earth type of discussions. I come down on the side of a standard guitar being strummed with the right hand and fretted with the left. It is neither a left or right handed instrument, it is a two-handed instrument. How many left-handed pianos are there?  I can't speak to the need for non-standard guitars, pianos or other instruments.

Offline close2u

  • Administrator
  • All Time Legend
  • *****
  • Posts: 11916
  • Good Vibes 475
  • Teesside, North East England.
Re: Southpaw
« Reply #14 on: February 15, 2020, 09:58:36 pm »
Bit hard on you Greg- being pulled up for repeating my poor choice of language  ;)
All good.
Have a productive guitar weekend  :)

That one passed my by somehow - thanks for pointing it out Brian - it is now duly erased ... you naught, naught boy. Soap & water!  ;)

 

Get The Forum As A Mobile App