Being brutal about it...you're way past this karaoke guitar stuff. As far as it goes, it's fine but in my view, good playing isn't about emulating another player, it's about expressing the music your way. I'm less interested in how like Jeff your vibrato is than I am in how expressive your vibrato is.
IMO (nothing humble about it
) You should record your own backing track and play over that. Based on the rhythm playing on Tuesday's Gone, I believe that's well within your capabilties and will be a much better indicator of your playing.